Let's dive into the art of constructing the Cincinnati Reds' batting order, a strategic puzzle that can make or break a team's success. The 2025 season showcased a select few hitters who dominated with over 650 plate appearances and an on-base percentage above .360, and TJ Friedl was among them.
But here's where it gets intriguing. While TJ's durability and on-base skills are undeniable, the leadoff spot is a hotly debated topic. Some argue for a classic prototype, while others suggest a more modern approach.
The lineup begins with TJ, but the real intrigue lies in the subsequent spots. Elly De La Cruz, a talented hitter, is set in the #3 spot, but the #2 position is a wildcard. Should Sal Stewart, a patient batter with power, claim that spot, or will Matt McLain, despite a modest 2025 performance, get the nod? Francona's decision here could shape the team's early-season dynamics.
The middle and back-half of the order present a fascinating mix of potential. Spencer Steer, Tyler Stephenson, Noelvi Marte, and Will Benson have shown streakiness, and JJ Bleday's potential adds depth. The handedness of the pitcher becomes a factor, with Dane Myers offering a unique option in the outfield. Nate Lowe, an unheralded minor league deal, could surprise and secure a key role.
Ke'Bryan Hayes, despite his defensive value, might find himself in the 9th spot, a decision that could spark debate. The Reds' lineup against right-handed pitchers and left-handed pitchers could look vastly different, and Francona's strategic choices will be crucial.
So, how would you build the ideal Reds lineup, and how would you adapt it for left-handed pitchers? Share your thoughts and let's discuss the art of batting order construction!
